Loading
Values Exchange

Vx POLL of the DAY (83): TOUGHER SPORTING CODES?

Avatar
23 Mar 2015 5 Respondents
80%
+2XPVote NowBoard
Amanda Lees
AUT Faculty of Health and Environmental Sciences
Mega Mind (40519 XP)
Advertisement
http://www.vxcommunity.com/request-a-demo/
Please login to save to your favourites
Vx POLL of the DAY (83): TOUGHER SPORTING CODES?

The captain of English football team Liverpool, Steven Gerrard, has apologised after stamping on the leg of opponent Ander Herrera during the weekend's match against Manchester United.

The UK's Indepedent reports that: 'Steven Gerrard has apologised for his extraordinary red card against Manchester United, 38 seconds after he came on for Liverpool at the start of the second half of their 2-1 home defeat to Louis Van Gaal’s side.

The United manager described the victory as one of the biggest wins of his illustrious career, and it puts United in pole position to claim the fourth Champions League place ahead of Liverpool and Tottenham, who they have beaten in their last two games. But it was overshadowed by the remarkable incident involving Gerrard.

The Liverpool captain was a second half substitute for Adam Lallana and was almost immediately dismissed for stamping on the leg of Ander Herrera. He gave an interview to Sky Sports in the aftermath of the game in which he apologised for his actions and took responsibility for the defeat. He said: “I’ve got to accept it. I’ve let my team-mates, manager and more importantly the supporters down and I take full responsibility for that.

“I think I’ve tried to avoid his tackle and I’ve reacted when I’ve seen his studs showing. But I’ve been in the game long enough to know when you do that with 45 minutes to play and a great opportunity to get back into the game, I take full responsibility.

“I’ve reacted to the initial tackle, but I don’t want to say too much more. I wanted to apologise to the supporters and I take full responsibility for the result.”

Read the article in full here: http://www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/premier-league/steven-gerrard-liverpool-captain-apologises-after-red-card-for-stamp-on-ander-herrera-10126001.html 

In the same game, Martin Skrtel alledgedly stamped on the opposing goalkeepr's foot.http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/news/martin-skrtel-stamp-david-de-5381810 

As a result of his misdemeanour, Martin Skrtel could yet face Football Association disciplinary action, if his actions have been seen to breach the FA Code of Conduct.   

Is intentional harm on the football field acceptable behaviour?

While many of us work in professions that have codes of practice, it is unlikely that our codes allow for us to assault others and not have our actions, if severe enough, considered by a court of law.

Is sport different?

Many sporting games include intense emotions and close physical contact; aggression is often a part of competitive behaviour, but should it be acceptable for sporting figures to intentionally do harm and then for those actions to just be seen as 'disciplinary' issues.

How would Gerrard, Skrtel and others (like Uruguayan striker Luis Suarez who bit other players at last years World Cup) be treated if their behaviour had taken place off the pitch, as members of the public?

Is sport 'just a game' and so therefore somehow different from real life situations, or should the same penalties apply for intentional actions on or off the field?

What do you think?

Image source 

It is proposed that professional sports players should face the same charges if found to have met the threshold for what would be considered a crime off the field